Archive
In Which Anastasia Writes A Review
Dearest readers,
I just wanted to take some time to share this review from my fiance Anastasia on the play “Informed Consent” by Zoe Laufer.
Anastasia’s take on the play is much more critical than others, and I find myself largely in agreement with her criticisms. The issues raised in “Informed Consent” are complicated and require careful and subtle understanding. To heighten the drama, it seems to me that complexity is substituted for one-dimensional conflicts that simplify and obscure, rather than elucidate, the problem.
The scientist has motivations that make her obsession with the research much more personal than what happened in real life, and I believe that this skews the conversation that the play tries to create against the scientific research aspect. Like other plays Anastasia has reviewed, such as Tom Stoppard’s “The Hard Problem,” it seems that the drive to create a compelling narrative for the heart overtakes the story for the brain. Complex ethical and philosophical issues can be explored in theater, but “Informed Consent” and “The Hard Problem” do the topics that they cover a disservice and, therefore, their audiences.
Make no mistake: I certainly believe that we should have these kinds of difficult conversations, especially the one that “Informed Consent” tries, but fails, to elucidate. But narratives can be a dangerous way to approach them, and these two plays show why. Ascribing emotional, personal motivations to the researcher undercuts the argument in favor of scientific research while doing nothing to really advance our understanding of the ethics involved between the Native American tribe and the researchers.
In case you’re wondering, in large part I sympathize with the Havasupai Tribe’s concerns and I think that the University and the researchers erred and acted somewhat unethically. But I do not believe that automatically makes the scientific questions raised and the answered found ethically wrong, or morally wrong. My hope is that, in the future, researchers will tread carefully and ensure that they do have consent for the kinds of genetic studies that they want to perform.
I also hope that if someone writes a play about future ethical issues in scientific endeavors they will not distill the side of science into a character with made-up questionable and personal motivations that were not present in the real events that seem to poison the well for science and scientific investigations.
To-Read List
- Dark Forces of Nature by Tristan Vick
- The Chronicles of Jegra: Gladiatrix of the Galaxy by Tristan Vick
- The Cold Dish by Craig Johnson
- Chasing Shadows by David Brin
- How We Became Posthuman by N. Katharine Hayles
- Invisible Planets edited by Ken Liu
- Stories of Your Life and Others by Ted Chiang
- Origin by Dan Brown
- The Science of Battlestar Galactica by Patrick Di Justo & Kevin R. Grazier
- The Girl Who Played with Fire #1 by Sylvain Runberg
- Dragon Teeth by Michael Crichton
- The Collapsing Empire by John Scalzi
- Sequence by Kenneth Rogers, Jr.
- All the King’s Men by Robert Penn Warren
- The Thing About Great White Sharks and Other Stories by Rebecca Adams Wright
- The Master and Margarita by Mikhail Bulgakov
- Persian Letters by Montesquieu
- Taming of Chance by Ian Hacking
- The Twentieth Century by Albert Robida
- Amish Vampires in Space by Kerry Nietz
Follow me on Twitter
My TweetsActivism
- American Atheists
- American Civil Liberties Union
- Center for Inquiry
- Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee
- Democratic Party
- Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee
- Doctors without Borders
- Freedom From Religion Foundation
- GLAAD
- March for Science
- Organizing for Action
- Pennsylvania Democratic Party
- Philadelphia Democratic City Committee
- Planned Parenthood Action Fun
- Richard Dawkins Foundation for Science and Reason
- The Society for Science-Based Medicine
Authors I Like
- Alain Robbe-Grillet
- Alan Moore
- Aldous Huxley
- Alexandre Dumas
- Allan Gurganus
- Andy Weir
- Art Spiegelman
- Arthur C. Clarke
- Blake Crouch
- Buzz Aldrin
- Col. Chris Hadfield
- Craig Johnson
- Daniel C. Dennett
- David Brin
- David Walton
- Douglas Adams
- Edgar Allan Poe
- Eric S. Rabkin
- Frank Miller
- Franz Kafka
- George Orwell
- George R.R. Martin
- Greg Bear
- Gregory Benford
- H.G. Wells
- Howard Zinn
- Ian Fleming
- Isaac Asimov
- Italo Calvino
- J.K. Rowling
- J.R.R. Tolkien
- John Scalzi
- Ken Liu
- Kurt Vonnegut
- Larry Niven
- Lawrence Lessig
- Liu Cixin
- Mary Shelley
- Matt Forbeck
- Max Brooks
- Michael Crichton
- Michio Kaku
- Olaf Stapledon
- Oscar Wilde
- Philip K. Dick
- Ray Bradbury
- Ray Kurzweil
- Robert A. Heinlein
- Scott Lynch
- Seamus Heaney
- Sean Carroll
- Sir Arthur Conan Doyle
- Sophocles
- Stanislaw Lem
- Stephen Hawking
- Stieg Larsson
- Thomas Piketty
- Tom Doyle
- Tristan Vick
- Ursula K. Le Guin
- Voltaire
- William Gibson
- William Shakespeare
Blogroll
- Advocatus Atheist
- Anne Wheaton dot Com
- Atheism and the City
- Balloon Juice
- Boxing Pythagoras
- Bridge Magazine
- Contrary Brin
- Fantasy-Fiction
- Fictional Heuristics
- Friendly Atheist
- Geekologie
- Geeks of Doom
- Godless in Dixie
- I Hear of Sherlock Everywhere
- io9
- James Fallows
- Lingua Franca
- Monitoring the Media
- Paul Krugman
- Philosophical Disquisitions
- Politics with Charles P. Pierce
- Sam Harris
- Ta-Nehisi Coates
- Talking Points Memo
- The A-Unicornist
- The Atheist Experience
- The Atlantic
- The Consumerist
- The Inverse Square Blog
- Think Progress
- WIL WHEATON dot NET
Cool Websites
- Ann Arbor Comedy Showcase
- Arthur C. Clarke Center for Human Imagination
- Genre Evolution Project
- TED Talks
- The Ben Heck Show
- The Gargoyle Humor Magazine
- The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy Game
- The Sherlock Holmes Society of London
- University of Michigan
- University of Michigan Alumni Association
- University of Michigan Department of English
- ZZ9 Plural Z Alpha
Podcasts I Listen To
- A Skeptics Guide to Conspiracy
- Bar Room Atheist
- Be Reasonable
- Biden's Briefing
- Citation Needed Podcast
- Cognitive Dissonance Podcast
- Coode Street Podcast
- Danthropology
- Distillations
- Exposing PseudoAstronomy
- Friendly Atheist Podcast
- Gaytheist Manifesto
- God Awful Movies
- Habeas Humor
- Horror 4H
- iFriends Podcast
- Inciting Incident
- Into the Impossible
- Irreligiosophy
- LeVar Burton Reads
- Mission to Zyxx
- Opening Arguments
- Philosophical Disquisitions Podcast
- Planetary Radio
- Point of Inquiry
- Radio Atlantic
- Reading, Short and Deep
- Real Atheology
- Reasonable Doubts Podcast
- Reel Pixel Podcast
- Robot Overlordz
- Serious Inquiries Only
- SF Signal Podcast
- Skeptically Challenged
- Skeptics with a K
- Star Talk Radio Show
- Thank God I'm Atheist
- The Atlantic Interview
- The Herd Mentality Podcast
- The How-To Heretic Podcast
- The Non Prophets
- The Right to Reason
- The Scathing Atheist
- The Sit and Spin Room
- The Skepticrat
- The Skeptics Guide to the Universe
- Trolling with Logic
- You Are Here
Professional Profiles
Science
- Better Health
- Denialism Blog
- Mayo Clinic's Advancing the Science
- NASA
- NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory
- Physics Database Free Science Books
- Science Blogs: Brains & Behavior
- Science Blogs: Humanities & Social Science
- Science Blogs: Life Science
- Science Blogs: Medicine & Health
- Science-Based Medicine
- The Extrasolar Planets Encyclopedia
- The Planetary Society
- The Quakometer
- what if?
- Why Evolution is True
Science Fiction
Social Media
Video Game News
Webcomics I Read
Flickr Photos
Recent Posts
Archives
Categories
Copyright Information

A Rushed Joke by Joshua Derke is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.